Model of the Month

[Enrico_sw]

3 minutes ago, peroxideblonde said:

what? more like the opposite imo..Rosie is liked while Emrata not at all, she should win easily with her

 

 

3 minutes ago, Matt! said:

 

 

[peroxideblonde]

7 minutes ago, Stromboli1 said:

 

I don't like either............. for different reasons.

there are people who don't like both but since this is a comp based on popularity Rosie wins hands down since she actually have fans while Emrata lol

[peroxideblonde]

1 minute ago, Enrico_sw said:

 

 

 

cleary you don't know how liked Rosie is, i have done 1204981758 competitions while you didn't, i know these things

[Matt!]

No fighting guys 

[Enrico_sw]

18 minutes ago, peroxideblonde said:

cleary you don't know how liked Rosie is, i have done 1204981758 competitions while you didn't, i know these things

 

I guess it depends on the voters and they aren't always the same. Also, the intransitivity plays a role in competitions with one-to-one rounds. BTW, we're supposed to vote on our personal opinions not on the prediction of how other people would vote

 

So, that's your opinion and I respect it, but I have another one.

[peroxideblonde]

9 minutes ago, Enrico_sw said:

 

I guess it depends on the voters and they aren't always the same. Also, the intransitivity plays a role in competitions with one-to-one rounds. BTW, we're supposed to vote on our personal opinions not on the prediction of how other people would vote

 

So, that's your opinion and I respect it, but I have another one.

they pretty much are always the same there are more "veterans" than new voters..anyway, that's the point of this round, he asked you who you think will lose against Emrata so you need to think about how other people will vote imo, is not just about your opinion

 

if you said Kate instead then i would have said maybe, i love Kate but she's at the same level of Emrata with a lot of haters and not a lot of fans

[Alizarine]

Alexina Graham

[Enrico_sw]

1 minute ago, peroxideblonde said:

they pretty much are always the same there are more "veterans" than new voters..

 

The intransitivity (I was sure we'd have some discussion about it at some point ) means that the choices of the rounds have an importance on the outcome (even when you do successive random matches to try to get more representative results). If A beats B, and B beats C, sometimes A doesn't beat C.

 

For example, if Rosie wasn't in the list, I would've said "no one", because I believe Emily can't beat anyone else, but my choice means she's Tier 12 (which is quite generous, I have to admit.... )

 

1 minute ago, peroxideblonde said:

he asked you who you think will lose against Emrata so you need to think about how other people will vote imo, is not just about your opinion

 

Unclear. I think he asks for our opinion (and it's easier than to read other people's minds).

 

@Mousematt You set the rules, so let us know what's the best interpretation

 

 

[Mousematt]

It's just your opinion. So if you'd vote for Emily over Rosie then you put Rosie (Even if you think she would beat other models lower down the rankings). It's basically doing 15 matches all at once so we don't have to wait 15 months for unpopular models to drop out of the rankings. I hope that makes sense.

 

So for example I'm voting for Alexina, Rosie, Isabeli, Hailey, Anthea, Bryana, Ming and Samantha over Emily. But I'd vote for Emily over Simone, so I reply:

 

Simone Villas Boas

 

even though I'd vote for all of the models below Simone over Emily

[peroxideblonde]

i really don't get this round is too much at the same time but we'll see the outcome i guess

[VBacz]

This is a nice idea, I really enjoy how creative and entertaining it is, thanks @Mousematt!

 

Kate Upton

[Stromboli1]

1 hour ago, peroxideblonde said:

there are people who don't like both but since this is a comp based on popularity Rosie wins hands down since she actually have fans while Emrata lol

 

She has fans, just not here.

[Mousematt]

At the moment the results look like this... (if Enrico votes for Emily to beat Rosie)

 

                                                                    Votes                     % of Votes Cast

Tier 11	Alexina Graham	1	8%
Tier 12	Rosie Huntington-Whiteley	1	17%
Tier 13	Isabeli Fontana		17%
Tier 14	Hailey Clauson		17%
Tier 15	Anthea Page		17%
Tier 16	Bryana Holly		17%
Tier 17	Ming Xi	2	33%
Tier 18	Samantha Gradoville		33%
Tier 19	Simone Villas Boas	2	50%
Tier 20	Kate Upton	3	75%
Tier 21	Imaan Hammam	1	83%
Tier 22	Niamh Adkins		83%
Tier 23	Hailey Outland		83%
Tier 24	Xenia Deli	1	92%
Tier 25	Noel Berry		92%
	No-one	1	100%

 

When Emily reaches 50% of votes cast she stops the drop, so at the moment she would end up beating Simone Villas Boas and so stop at the bottom of Tier 18, with Simone one place below her at the top of Tier 19. All the models she has beaten (Alexina down to Samantha) would move up one place into the next Tier (so Alexina would take Emily's place in Tier 10 and so on)

 

So obviously if you just there's nothing stopping you voting tactically, either to drop her all the way to #101 by saying no-one, or to keep her where she is by saying Alexina. 

 

[peroxideblonde]

7 minutes ago, Stromboli1 said:

 

She has fans, just not here.

i know, i'm talking about BZ..and we all know why she have fans outside of here  

[Stromboli1]

1 minute ago, peroxideblonde said:

i know, i'm talking about BZ..and we all know why she have fans outside of here  

 

Okay and yep.

[Enrico_sw]

35 minutes ago, Mousematt said:

It's just your opinion. So if you'd vote for Emily over Rosie then you put Rosie (Even if you think she would beat other models lower down the rankings). It's basically doing 15 matches all at once so we don't have to wait 15 months for unpopular models to drop out of the rankings. I hope that makes sense.

 

Yes, it's clear. It's the way I voted.

 

BTW, thanks for adding new rules like this one, it adds some fun

 

13 minutes ago, Mousematt said:

At the moment the results look like this... (if Enrico votes for Emily to beat Rosie)

 

Actually, I'm having second thoughts... I think I might've been too generous (even if I don't like Rosie either). So, if you allow me to change my vote , I'll have this strategic vote you talked about, and I'll say "no one".

[Mousematt]

7 minutes ago, Enrico_sw said:

Actually, I'm having second thoughts... I think I might've been too generous (even if I don't like Rosie either). So, if you allow me to change my vote , I'll have this strategic vote you talked about, and I'll say "no one".

 

No problem

[jkjk]

There are three or four that could be close, but I say:

 

no one

[lostdiadem]

No one.

[Grievous]

Was Emily picked at random or what?