She (or whoever wins) will be considered a rookie 

Big yes for Denise for me.

1 hour ago, Clauds said:

Denise is a nope for me, Liz is a yes and pray she makes it.

 

A rookie class with Alexis, Liz, McKenna, Cami Morrone, Bryna Holly and Lorena Rae would be the dream  

 

+1

 

Nope, no, nein, nem  

 

 

Yeah, Denise would be truly awful. 

 

 

(I'd rather have Liz or Denise than Bo, so long as we're picking from models who appeared in this Guess ad)

Yes, for Denise. Great boobs. 

14 hours ago, Sunshiine said:

 

 

Yes!

I want both Denise and Liz. But Denise has to be there!

7 hours ago, SympathysSilhouette said:

I want both Denise and Liz. But Denise has to be there!

 

Cosigned!

Denise's niche has already been filled by Bo

1 minute ago, Prettyphile said:

Denise's niche has already been filled by Bo

 

If you say so, she doesn't appeal to whatever niche I'm supposed to be into. But why not, keep her, add Denise, and get rid of one of the several models in SI filling no niche at all. 

@Prettyphile

 

What is their niche?

Tall, slender (yet curvy) dark brunette, fair skinned models without any kind of nepotism backing, fame or famous boyfriends to distinguish them from each other..  To the average man looking at the magazine if you put both Bo and Denise's pictures in the magazine, I'm guessing that most men won't be able to tell the two apart.

 

If Denise makes the magazine I can promise you that it's because Guess wants her pushed, or she begins to date someone very famous (needs to happen soon), and or she made quick BFF's with Darcie or MJ... because as of now she offers nothing to the SI Swim Standard.

2 hours ago, Prettyphile said:

To the average man looking at the magazine if you put both Bo and Denise's pictures in the magazine, I'm guessing that most men won't be able to tell the two apart.

 

That's... a sweeping and un-provable assertion but ok.

 

The rest is fine. If nepotism or famous boyfriends matter, and I suspect they do, then all Denise has is "was photographed on a beach--among a dozen others--with Leo DiCaprio once."

Does it really matter if it's an unprovable assertion? I'll stand by it, the two girls look very similar (not face wise) and have nothing to set them apart from each other, and to the average non-fashion guy who's looking at SI Swimsuit, chances are strong he won't be able to tell them apart at first glance, and Si doesn't want that for their models, they want their girls to stand apart.

 

This kind of thing happens all the time with blonde models. Ever heard of the VS blonde wack-a-mole game, aka interchangeable blondes game? Even though it's been years with certain models working under the brand.... if you ask random people in the street to pick who Stella Maxwell vs Lindsay E is you might have a few people who know who the are, but for the majority it'll be a guess. 

 

http://www.justjaredjr.com/2016/05/13/stella-maxwell-looks-incredible-during-victorias-secret-photo-shoot/

But Denise's face isn't super jank like Bo's.  

I'm a no on Denise too though. 

1 hour ago, toodarnhot said:

But Denise's face isn't super jank like Bo's.  

I'm a no on Denise too though. 

It's not about the face, it's about every other box that can be checked Bo's face isn't that bad.

17 minutes ago, Prettyphile said:

It's not about the face, it's about every other box that can be checked Bo's face isn't that bad.

Bo's body is 10/10 but there is just something that I can't put my finger on about her face that just bothers so much. 

 

I think Guess has the opposite problem as VS though- they've got a lot of interchangeable brunettes.  Olga, Bo, Denise, even Solveig to a point. 

 

Edit: Speaking of Bo, she made #1 on Vogue's Bombshell list, but Rachel Hilbert made the list too so I would take the rest of their choices with a grain of salt.  

 

http://www.vogue.com/13435829/who-will-be-modelings-next-bombshell/

 

Look at the list of girls on that list... and think of how many of them work for SI, or how many of them have gone to castings.  Interesting

 

Bo - SI

Hailey - SI/Cover Girl

Nina - SI/Cover Girl

Jariah - SI

Daniela Braga - Castings

Camila Morrone  - Castings

Rachel - Castings

Robin Marjolein - Beach Bunny (SI Loves Beach Bunny with triple )

I don't think the list was supposed to be a rank so Bo is not #1, I think it was random ordering. I sincerely doubt Vogue out of all magazines would put Bo as #1 over Ana W's new pet Camila Morrone or former HF darling Hailey Clauson.

 

And I like Rachel, but she does not belong in that list at all 

Rachel casted for SI as well, Pretty.