Jump to content
Forum Look Announcement

Fragrance vs. Cosmetics Commercial Ultimate Battle...to the Death! ^_^

Featured Replies

  • Author

At least a couple more would be good :) . As a side note though, one interresting irony of the polls is that the commercials with male models have the most 5s whereas if I were to do a male commercial comp probably half the people would vote :laugh::ninja: . Or at least the average male model would probably get higher scores whereas the females are still more popular.

I´ve never been much interested in male models :idk: but good commercial is a good commercial, no matter who is there :yes:

Marloes could have been writhing around with The Elephant Man, and I'd still give it 5 :ninja:

Maybelline: 2

Fuel for Life: 5 - Lol at choosing such a cheesy Disco track.

Chanel: 5 - Simple and glamouros.

Valentino: 5 - Mona! :wub:

Mary Kay: 1.5 - No, no, no- I really hate the song. Everything is a little bit too happy for me here.

Estee Lauder: 3.5 - Pretty.

Maybelline - Typical Maybelline but it still works 3.5

Diesel - Sexy but not too tacky, fun, with a lot of energy. Love it 5

Chanel - I love the luxury feel of this commercial 4.5

Valentino - Good but not great 3.5

Mary Kay - Cheezy 1.5

Estee Lauder - Cute 3.5

  • Author

I'll work on making this a little easier on the eyes :ninja: ...

ROUND 1

Pair 1

Cheryl Cole Loreal - 1.91875

Raquel & Natasha Gucci Perfume Commercial - 1.6

Winner: Cosmetics

ROUND 2

Pair 2

Gisele - 3.5

Maybelline - 2.272

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 3

Chanel - 3.972

Lux - 1.88

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 3

Pair 4

Scarlett Johansson D&G The One - 2.5

Josie Maran Volum Express Maybelline New York - 2.6294

Winner: Cosmetics

Pair 5

Angie Everhart Finesse Commercial - 1.08823

Gwen Stefani's Harajuku Lovers Fragrance - 1.4294

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 4

Pair 6

Veronica Varekova Nivea Mascara - 2

"Ricci Ricci" Perfume Commercial with Jessica Stam - 3.55

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 7

Taylor Swift CoverGirl NatureLuxe - 2.565

Kenzo Flower Fragrance - 2.825

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 5

Pair 8

Revlon Colorstay Lipstick - 3.1333

Victoria's Secret Fragrance - 3.22857 (to be altered as one voted before commercial was changed)

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 9

Fit Me Foundation Maybelline New York - 3.453

-Midnight Poison by C Dior - 3.64

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 6

Pair 10

Drew Barrymore Covergirl Makeup Collection - 2.44375

Britney Spears Curious Perfume - 1.83125

Winner: Cosmetics

Pair 11

Estee Lauder More than Mascara - 2

Valentino "Very Valentino" -2.525

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 7

Pair 12

Bianca - 2.6875

Emily - 4.09375

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 13

-Garnier - 1.9375

Prada - 1.53125

Winner: Cosmetics

ROUND 13

Pair 14

Garnier - 1.66428

Kate - 3.19999

Winner: Cosmetics

Pair 15

Revlon - 2.307

Cacharel - 2.8718

Winner: Cosmetics

ROUND 14

Pair 16

Shania Twain Revlon Colorstay Makeup - 2.142857

Britney Spears Fantasy Fragrance - 1.55

Winner: Cosmetics

Pair 17

Aishwarya Rai Loreal - 2.0769

Juicy Couture Fragrance - 3.53571

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 15

Pair 18

Maybelline - 2.916

Miss Dior - 3.75

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 19

Julie Ordon Chanel - 3.0416

Evanteline Lily Cool Water Woman - 2.7083

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 16

Pair 20

Milla Jovovich L'Oreal Rouge Pulp - 2.708

Yves Saint Laurent YSL Paris Perfume - 1.508

Winner: Cosmetics

Pair 21

Scarlett Johansson L'Oreal HIP - 1.683

Daria Werbowy Lancome Hypnose Senses - 3.425

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 17

Pair 22

Lancome Lipstick - 2.1125

Theorema Fendi - 2.46875

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 23

Color Rich L'Oreal - 2.6875

Stella McCartney - 2.9625

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 18

Pair 24

Anna Sui - 1.87

Forbidden Rose - 2.266

Winner: Fragrance

Pair 25

Dior Addict - 2.583

Chanel Number 5 - 3.875

Winner: Fragrance

ROUND 19

Pair 26

Maybelline New York Fit Me Foundation - 3.0066

Inspire Perfume - 1.1066

Pair 27

L'Oreal Perfect Slim - 1.94

With Love Perfume - 1.613

ROUND 20

Pair 28

Maybelline New York Fit Me Foundation - 3.0066

Inspire Perfume - 1.1066

Pair 29

L'Oreal Perfect Slim - 1.94

With Love Perfume - 1.613

ROUND 21

Pair 30

Maybelline - 3.43

Givenchy - 2.66

Pair 31

Max Factor - 1.9

Versace - 2.125

ROUND 22

Pair 32

Lux - 34.9

Estee Lauder Pomegrante Power - 29.7

Pair 33

Cover Perfume - 35

Dior Pure Poison - 33.1

ROUND 23

Pair 34

Maybelline - 3.225

Guerlain - 3.34375

Pair 35

Maybelline - 2.59375

Dolce - 3.4375

RESULTS

Loreal = 1.86

Guerlain Mahora = 3.26

Maybelline Cat Eye Mascara = 2.43

Guilty Gucci = 3.86

RESULTS

Debon = 2.59375

VS Dream = 2.84

Maybelline Lash Stiletto = 4.25

Valentino V = 2.4

RESULTS

Revlon - 32.2/2.4769

Christian Lacroix - 38.3/2.946

YSL - 34.3/2.858

Dior - 21.5/1.6538

RESULTS

Loreal - 3.6

Thermasilk - 3.75

Nina Ricchi - 3.37857

Robert Cavali - 3.25

RESULTS

Versache Pur Femme - 2.115

Cover Girl Silk Foundation - 2.4615

Olay Body Wash - 2.964

Angel Thierry Mugler - 2.721

RESULTS

Mary Kay Color - 37/15=2.466

Miss Dior Cherie - 44.5/15=2.966

Dior Addict Makeup - 2.066

Bruno Avelain Lanvin Oxygene - 52.7/3.513

RESULTS

Mary Kay Commercial - 3.375

Guerlain Inastand Magic - 2.625

Maybelline New York Watershine Elixer - 1.958

Gaultier Madame Perfume - 2.875

  • Author

Avon Clear Skin Professional (Nominated by Jennka)

Scarlett Cacharell (Nominated by UmbreallaBeach)

Revlon Super Lustrous Lipstick (Nominated by sagitario)

Boss Orange Fragrance (Nominated by UmbrellaBeach)

Avon Aney Emulsions (Nominated by Jennka)

Cacharel: Amor Amor (Nominated by UmbreallaBeach)

  • Author

Avon - 2 Kindof liked the hand motion :) .

Scarlett - 1.5

Revlon - 1.5

Boss - 1

Avon - 2.5 Nice try :) .

Cacharel - 1 I need either my involvement or an extremely moving story (that includes an epic adventure) to make guy on girl kissing relevant for me, but nice try :) .

Avon 3

Cacharell 4

Revlon 1

Boss 3

Avon Emulsions 1.5

Amor Amor 2.5

For COP11

Avon 1

Cacharell 1

Revlon 5

Boss 1

Avon Emulsions 5-for having pretty woman according to her

Amor AMor 1

Avon 2.5

Cacharel 2

Revlon 1

Hugo Boss 5

Avon 4.5 (only Nicole's Trunfio part)

Cacharel 2

Avon Clearskin - 3 Decent, gets the point across.

Scarlett - 2 was cute and catchy, but I don't remember it after it played.

Revlon - 4 it was old school, when it was new school.

Boss - 2 I'm sure I'd like the fragrance, but I could only think of how the director was telling her how to emote for the camera.

Avon Anew - 3 UK gets the better Anew ads than we do in the states.

(I hope I did it right, first time doing this)

Cacharel - 1

Avon:
3.5

- Simple and to the point. Could do without the teenie bop music though.

Scarlett Cacharell:
0.8
:angry:

- INCOMING NERD RAGE

STOP FUCKING WITH CURE SONGS!

STOP FUCKING WITH CURE SONGS!

STOP FUCKING WITH CURE SONGS!

The utter blasphemy of that woman thinking she could sing one of his songs!!!

All better now.
:heart:

Revlon:
4

- Simple and to the point.

Boss Orange Fragrance:
2

- .... it's the Beattles. Don't do it.

Avon Aney Emulsions:
4.5

- Simple and to the point, plus it has Nicole in it.

Cacharel:
0.5

- DO NOT under ANY circumstances wanna hear slurping while people kiss. That's just nasty.

Avon- She won miss Universe?! :blink: Annoying voices, but i liked the colours,lol - 2

Scarlett Cacharell- That was cute && i love Skye- 4.5

Revlon- I liked it but why was Claudia trying to be all sexy wearing those dresses and shaking around....i thought this was a lipstick ad? - 4

Boss- Loving the music- and Sienna looked quite adorable but it was kinda pointless .... - 2.5

Avon Anew- Once again,simple & got to the point- beautiful models too- 4.3

Cacharell- DAYUM, they were really going at it weren't they? that dude was trying to eat her face off..... i don't get this one.... 1

Avon: 2.5 - Simple, effective, but fairly unremarkable.

Scarlett Cacharel: 4 - Very very (very) cute.

Revlon: 3 - Very much of its time, but it gets to the point quickly and holds your attention.

Boss: 5 - Though I'm not generally that fussed about Sienna, I've always found this ad rather magnificent. :heart:

Avon Anew: 3.5 - Pretty standard stuff but the nice use of primary colours makes it more memorable than most.

Cacharel: 2 - Get a room guys. Oh, you already did. :pinch:

Avon: 3

Scarlett Cacharell: 3.8

Revlon: 4.5

Boss: 2

Avon Anew: 2

Cacharell: 1

Avon Clear Skin - The commercial is ok, but I don't like when they try to get some "scientist" to approve of the product 2

Scarlett - I just like Skye 3

Revlon - Claudia looks good I guess 3

Hugo Boss - For what's happening in the commercial, it's a little too long 2

Avon Anew - I don't like the use of young women in wrinkle reducing products, other than that, it's alright 2.5

Cacharel - Very cute 3.5

Avon: 3. Not bad, and not annoying.

Scarlett: 4. Pretty cute. The music fits well, although it's a bad rendition :/

Revlon: 1.5. Annoying :| +0.5 for the colour idea.

Boss: 3.5. Speaking of bad covers.. <_< A bit long, but charming if a little pointless

Avon: 2.5. Dull and without much polish, but Nicole FTW :brows:

Cacharel: 5. Love it

Avon Clear Skin: 1 - Uhm "embarassing Acne"? Kinda stupid. The commercial is ok but I really dislike this woman. Miss Universe can not convince me to buy anything, sorry.

Scarlett Cacharel: 5 - Yes, I do agree with Pretty but I still think this is very cute and well made.

Revlon: 3.5 - This is kinda...good.

Boss Orange: 4.5 - I like that it is fresh and careless but it's still a little bit staged. Just a bit. Sienna is adorable, though.

Avon Aney Emulsions: 1.5 - Those faces are a little bit too plain for my taste. Too much high-tech in this one! :D

Cacharel Amor Amor: 1 - Does not touch me. At all. :ninja:

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.