Jump to content
Forum Look Announcement

Featured Replies

Black Eyed Peas: 0
Sounds even worse today than it did back then. Luckily, I can now look back on it and laugh.

Alanis Morissette: 6
Not a fan of Alanis by any stretch, but at least I now know she's not completely humourless (unless calling your album "Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie" counts as a joke). Perhaps I've misjudged her. :laugh:

Original x0
Cover x5

OG - 10

Cover - 0

OG - 5

Cover - 0

omg ive been forgetting to vote too in my fav competition!!!!

original-0

cover-3

sorry dont like it much!

PS: OOOOPS :lol:

2.5 each :)))

:whistle:

It was cool to listen to Alanis' version, completely different to BEP's but I don't like it at all :| I guess "My humps" should just be trashy the way it is :idk:

Original 2

Cover 3

2.5 each :unsure:

  • Author

^Thanks for joining in :)

omg ive been forgetting to vote too in my fav competition!!!!

original-0

cover-3

sorry dont like it much!

anjelina, you forgot to distribute 5 points amongst the two :wave:

  • Author

Results

My Humps

[nominated by donbot]

Original version by Black Eyed Peas scored 1.7/10

Cover version by Alanis Morissette scored 5.6/10

Overall preference weighting goes to the COVER VERSION with 78.8% of the vote

12.5% of people preferred the original version

75% of people preferred the cover version

12.5% of people liked them equally

  • Author

The Man Who Sold The World

[nominated by Michael*]

Original by David Bowie

Cover by Nirvana

HOW TO VOTE:

1. Rate the original version objectively out of 10

2. Rate the cover version objectively out of 10

3. Distribute 5 points amongst the two, based on how much you prefer one version over the other

  • Author

Love both versions :heart:

David Bowie: 9.5

Nirvana: 9.5

Original x 2.5

Cover x 2.5

Absolutely love both. Slightly prefer the Nirvana version, but not enough to seperate them when distributing my five points.

David Bowie: 9
Nirvana: 9.5

Original x2.5
Cover x2.5

David Bowie: 4

Nirvana: 8

Original x 1

Cover x 4

Bowie is outstanding, but nirvana outdid him here

Original: 7.6

Cover: 8.4

Original: x1.5

Cover: x3.5

Original: 8

It's really a great song

Cover: 10

And that is an amazing cover

David Bowie: x2

Nirvana: x3

David Bowie: 7

Nirvana: 9.5

Original x 1

Cover x 4 - Kurt's voice is just too amazing & he was so cute in a "i look like a hobo.i need a wash" kinda way :blush:

  • Author

Results

The Man Who Sold The World

[nominated by Michael*]

Original version by David Bowie scored 7.3/10

Cover version by Nirvana scored 9/10

Overall preference weighting goes to the COVER VERSION with 65% of the vote

0% of people preferred the original version

62.5% of people preferred the cover version

37.5% of people liked them equally

  • Author

Like a Prayer

[nominated by anjelina]

Original by Madonna

Cover by Mad'House

HOW TO VOTE:

1. Rate the original version objectively out of 10

2. Rate the cover version objectively out of 10

3. Distribute 5 points amongst the two, based on how much you prefer one version over the other

Original 7

Cover 6.5

Original x 3

Cover x2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.