Edited January 6, 200718 yr by Qball

Interesting poll, both quite big in business, very thin in life and yes... Voted for Hilary, she's more sympathic

First time a blonde won again a brunette in such a poll for me Oo

even tough Duff is skinny it can be fixed....lohan is just not that attractive skinny or a little more heavier..

Hilarys the better looking one..

I used to like Lindsay Lohan before she went crazy/turned into a media whore I never liked Hillary duff...hmm I actually think Lohan's a slightly better actress, not that I'm saying she's good but her role in The Parent Trap when she was young is still better than anything I've seen Duff do, so I guess I vote for Lohan...

I don't like either of them but since I'd like to watch Duff rot in the depths of hell, I'll vote for Lohan.

What Ashley said.

I don't like either of them but since I'd like to watch Duff rot in the depths of hell, I'll vote for Lohan.

i HATE DUFF! She needs to get hit by a truck. I cannot express my hatred for her.

I think Lohan is okay, so obiously my vote is Lohan.

Lohan

I like them both, but Duff has become really thin lately.

Hm..Why do people hate Duff so much??! She's not as bitchy, media whoring, Paris Hilton wannabe as Lohan. Plus I hate Lohan cuz I know people in her posse, and even they say she's a bitch! Lohan is just :yuckky: , looks and personality. I vote Duff cuz she's better looking (when not anorexic) and cuz I knew Adam Lamberg , Gordo from Lizzie McGuire in high school.

i love gordo

Hm..Why do people hate Duff so much??!

Hmm... I think it's her teeth... Dunno why, though, I like her looks... when curvy, that is!

I feel the same thing as Lullaby about Duff...i hate her so bad :|

So yeah, im not a huge fan of Lohan but she's okay and anybody's (or almost ) better than Hilary :|

Hilary Duff

now, i'd actually have to go with Hilary. In early year, i would go with Lohan, but lately i am not liking her look or the way she acts really. Im finding, tho Hilary can be a lil annoying and seems a bit too perky sometimes, she seems very sweet, good role model, and tho i would've said Lohan years back(she used to look like a cute lil redhead porcelain doll), I'm gonna say Hilary also in the looks department too. I mean, at least she looks clean

Duff Duff Duff Duff Duff Duff Duff Duff Duff

Hm..Why do people hate Duff so much??! She's not as bitchy, media whoring, Paris Hilton wannabe as Lohan. Plus I hate Lohan cuz I know people in her posse, and even they say she's a bitch! Lohan is just :yuckky: , looks and personality. I vote Duff cuz she's better looking (when not anorexic) and cuz I knew Adam Lamberg , Gordo from Lizzie McGuire in high school.

Gordo hehehe

I don't reaqlly like either of the too... but I definitely hate Lohan!

lahan is so over in every thing

she acts so stupid

voted for duff

Lindsay Lohan