Jump to content
Forum Look Announcement

Fragrance vs. Cosmetics Commercial Ultimate Battle...to the Death! ^_^

Featured Replies

Mary Kay - 3

Miss Dior - 2

Dior Addict - 2

Bruna Avelain - 5

Mary Kay: 3.5 - Not half bad. Liked the constantly moving background a lot.

Miss Dior: 2 - Top marks for production values, bottom marks for substance.

Dior Addict: 1.5 - I expected to like this one a lot more than I did. Very well shot but generally unmemorable and too long by half.

Bruna Avelain: 3.5 - The constant jumping from scene to scene was too jarring for my liking, though I'd imagine it would be quite effective in catching attention on TV.

  • Author

RESULTS

Mary Kay Color - 2.466

Miss Dior Cherie - 2.966

Dior Addict Makeup - 2.066

Bruno Avelain Lanvin Oxygene - 3.513

Mary Kay Commercial (Nominated by Jennka)

Guerlain L'Instant Magic

Maybelline New York Watershine Elixer (Nominated by sagitario)

Gaultier Madame Perfume (Nominated by Squeege Bechinheim)

  • Author

Mary Kay Commercial - 3 nice lips and cute presentation :) .

Guerlain - 5 I wish it were someonen I was more attracted to, but one of the best dresses ever and love the staircase thing :) .

Maybelline - 2.5

Gaultier - 2 nice try :) .

I would not mind 6 :)

Mary Kay 3

Guerlain 4

Maybelline 3

Gaultier 2

Mary Kay 2

Guerlain 1

maybelline 1

Gaultier 3

Mary Kay 4

Guerlain L'Instant Magic 2

Maybelline NY 1

Gaultier Madame Perfume 5

Mary Kay - Love the energy 4.5

Guerlain - The visible buttcrack is so vulgar 1.5

Maybelline - Nothing special 2

Gaultier - Agyness is overplaying her role 2.5

Mary Kay Commercial: 2.5

- First 15 seconds made the point, the rest irk'd me.

Guerlain: 1.5

- Where's she going with this? Climbing for 30+ secs, plus buttcrack, lost patience and I have zero idea what's being sold..... again O.o. SHORTER and to the point please.

Maybelline: 1.5

- Engrish please.

Gaultier: 2

- It's Aggy losing her shit... and poorly at that, but it's still Aggy

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.