Claudia x2

Mary-Kate x1

Claudia Schiffer x3

MK x 2.5

Claudia x 0.5

Claudia x3

Mary Kate x3

MK x2

Claudia x1

Claudia x3

Mary-Kate x3

UK September 2008 - Mary-Kate Olsen x 3

Claudia x 3

Claudia x3

Claudia Schiffer x3

Claudia schiffer x3

I had actually forgotten I nominated that :| . I don't own any Elle and wanted to get a nomination in before time ran out and it was the best I found on google images . Anyway, definitely Claudia x3 for me .

Voting is closed!

Results:

Claudia Schiffer - 40 - won

Mary-Kate Olsen - 30 - lost

The Best Elle Cover

~ Consolation ~

-Round 17-

(by jal718)US April 1987 - Paulina Porizkova vs France May 2008 - Hilary Rhoda(by Vanessaaa)

vs

Rules:

1. Vote for your favorite cover.

2. You can vote three times (split it how you want).

3. The cover with the most votes wins.

Start voting!

Hilary Rhoda x2

Paulina Porizkova x1

Rhoda x3

Paulina x 2

Hilary x 1

Paulina x 3