Revlon - 2.5 - not a fan of hers, but cute anyway.
Emily - 3 I know you're thinking she hasn't learned to model yet and that may be true, but she sure is pretty and has kindof a pleasant way about her. She's like your partner in lab who takes off the glasses and everyone else notices her magically, but you knew all along . Though it seems more could have been done with it as well and her lack of genuine sensuality (which is made up for by girl next door sweetness in Maybelline ads) makes it look more like a runaway girl than a wilderness woman, but well shot.
Garnier - 2.5
Prada - 1 - hated it, but nice try.