I'm stumped so I'll cheat a little.

 

 

"Sail Away Sweet Sister" / Queen

 

Amazing song too! One of those hidden gems in The Game

 

Sister Disco - The Who

"Disco Duck" / Rick Dees & His Cast of Idiots

 

(Good luck!)

Challenge accepted!

 

Duck Down / The Roots

Down by the Water / The Decemberists

^ on the Duck song

 

 

"Water Music Suite in D Major" / George Frederick Handel

Major Leagues / Pavement

I fear I may have killed the game. How about we dial it back to #485 and 'water'...

 

Water Song / Aerosmith

(The) Song Remains The Same - Led Zeppelin

Same Love / Macklemore & Ryan Lewis

Love Her Madly - The Doors

Madly In Love With You / Sean McConnell

You Lost Me / Sleigh Bells

"Me And My Shadow" / Ted Lewis

Shadow of the Season - Screaming Trees

Seasons Change / Expose

"Change The World" / Eric Clapton

World Wide Suicide - Pearl Jam

Suicide Life / Eels

"Life Is Just A Bowl Of Cherries" / Rudy Vallee