Totally NOT surprised TBH I was initially skeptical about what happened b/c 1) The way he was describing the incident sounded very questionable and shady. 2) He is a shady guy to start with who is quite a douchey attention whore (watch his reality show. Enough said)
From what I heard it was a cover up for bad behavior. Ryan and a few other swimmers were wasted so they started acting like assholes. They were wreaking havoc and publicly urinating at some gas station on their way back to the Village from boozing. There was some altercation between the swimmers and gas station employee. The employee pulled a gun on them but never pulled the tigger nor did he/she rob them. Someone called the cops, they show up, broke-up the altercation, and charges were dropped. Then the next day or so the swimmer came up with the lame story I originally posted