Oh, there, there guys .
Thanks Mona and Sarah .
FRANCY, she was rating the use of pics as the evidence of someone being a great runway model, rather than the model herself .
To FRANCY's defense, being someone who works in fashion (and lives in Italy on top of that), seeing a 3 for Isabeli as a runway model can understandably be pretty surprising and annoying. I'm sure anyone who works in fashion who sees a 3 for such would have a few things to say , not that that excuses the nature of how these things are said .
Both FRANCY and pheno are right about the iconic status. Both are right about her iconic status where THEY live.
*edit* and the "learn something about fashion" is definitely out of line .
Pretty is right about the need for VIDEOS to fully judge runway, as one can't really judge a walk from pics . However, guys, the pics are moreso of a guide, so if there isn't enough evidence, its best to either not vote or ask before voting rather than just give a low score .
So, in the end, one side still gave a low score without said videos and the other still never provided said videos on top of that so... ....
To simply say, "well I'll provide a video, could you revote after?" Then for the other to say, "sure, thank you" so on....would have likely been much better....but that's neither here nor there now...Anyway...
So, how about a revote based upon a video and call it a truce ?