I agree that they do use her a lot, and they do seem to like her, and that is why I believe she would have made it if she had worked harder to tone things up. Not to mention photos are very different than runway. Just because they use her a lot, that does not mean that they like her body, or all of it anyway. Most of her photos are either cropped above her belly button, or they have something covering her stomach, but they hardly ever show her tummy. What they do show is her face and boobs, but hardly any clear shots of her abdominal region. So I would not say that they think highly of her whole body, because they have indicated an issue with her stomach in my opinion. However, they can avoid that issue in photos, but that's not something so easily done on the runway. I am also not sure about this idea that every girl they pick for photos is someone they think would be good for the runway. I think the biggest thing is the fact that she didn't work out as much as she should have, because they even mentioned in the casting video that they have seen more of a working out trend this year, opposed to previous years. It seems that everyone knew to step it up this year, even the new girls, but apparently not Barbara. So again, it's not surprising or odd to me that she didn't make it.