My vote goes to Evan Not only was Kiera's main claim to fame the pirates series, (which were nothing to rave about imo, at least not on her end of the acting) her next big movie that stands out was Atonement. Which while it had the potential to be a decent movie the sad reality is that after the 13 year old girl in the begining of the movie was gone the rest of it fell to shit, (thus I have very little to say about Kiera's acting there) and then there was king arthur... there are no words for the atrociousness that was King Arthur. As for Pride and Prejudice, if you've ever seen the original A&E special that was done, (roughly 7 hours in length, though it was cut down to weekly segments) I highly doubt you would find anything original or brilliant in the way of acting from the movie released recently. Domino was just that a flop, and none of the other movies were good enough to actually stand out in my mind as being stellar or horrible. So I would definately have to go with Evan for this round.