Jennifer or Madonna

Jennifer

Katy Perry or Jen Love hewitt

Neither

Angelina Jolie or Vanessa Paradis

Vanessa Paradis

Holly Marie Combs or Rose McGowen

Rose or Keira Knightley

Keira Knightley

Jessica Alba or Jessica Beil

Alba

Jessica Alba or Heather Marks

Alba

Jennifer Love Hewitt or Alyssa Milano

Alyssa or Samantha Mathis

Alyssa

Jennifer Anniston or Madonna

Neither

Penelope Cruz or Shakira

Penelope

Penelope Cruz or Julia Roberts

Tough call - Penelope Cruz

Liv Tyler or Anne Hathaway

Liv

Liv Tyler or Christina Milian

Liv Tyler

Demi Moore or Drew Berrymore

Demi or Jessica Biel

Jessica

Jessica Biel or Jenny Garth

Jessica

Jenny McCarthy or Gena Lee Nolin

Neither

Kim Kardashian or Rosalyn Sanchez

Rosalyn Sanchez

Selma Hayek or Poppy Montgomery