Ok, so I was bored. Maybe this is a stupid poll, or maybe not.

I think Dave is the obvious choice. However, Adrian had some really fast licks, so I'm not sure. I'm voting for Dave anyway, though

Here's a cool video of the original band playing "Phantom Of The Opera"

http://64.224.182.233/maiden_phantom.mov

I have to agree with you, Dave is the best in Iron Maiden.

Dave has the best tone and plays the fastest and cleanest solos. Yet, I can't say I don't like Adrian, although Dave gets my vote.

I can't really decide between Murray or Smith

Adrian Smith rules

I think Dave

I just got A Real Dead One, and I think Janick is really good.

It seems like him and Dave are shredding a bit more on this than the older stuff I have...